Why Did I get married was a GREAT movie,I cannot wait for this to come out on DVD so I can watch it over and over again.there are moments in his movies where the goings-ons seem a bit too far-fetched or too sappy/mushy. When considering the casting, cinematography, and story line, this is easily one of his best films.dont know about the movie forums critisicizing the movie,4 great movies under his(Tyler Perry) belt,its the start.Still has a long way to go though.